Why Do We Expect Victims to Be Perfect While Defending Criminals?

We have a serious problem with how we talk about self-defense. Every time a criminal commits something violent and unforgivable, the conversation somehow flips — and instead of focusing on the person who caused the chaos, we start dissecting whether the person who stopped it reacted “perfectly.”

Ab & Preach recently dropped a video reacting to the Bondi attack in Australia, and one moment in particular cuts straight to the heart of this debate.

Abba asks the question everyone avoids:

When someone has already decided to take lives… do you now owe them your own safety in order to spare them?

That’s not a hypothetical.

That’s the reality civilians face when evil shows up without warning.

This video isn’t about glorifying violence.

It’s about confronting the impossible standards we place on law-abiding people while constantly excusing the behavior of criminals.

We demand:

• Perfect judgment in chaos

• Flawless reactions under stress

• Moral purity in seconds

• And zero mistakes — ever

Meanwhile, the criminal gets infinite grace.

That disconnect is what this video breaks down.

We talk about:

• The difference between stopping a threat vs punishment

• Why “disarming” someone doesn’t guarantee safety

• The fantasy vs reality of self-defense

• Why civilians will never react perfectly — and shouldn’t be expected to

• And the uncomfortable truth about intent, chaos, and survival

This is not legal advice.

This is not a call to violence.

This is a reality check.

I highly recommend watching Ab & Preach’s original video in full for context:

Then come back and tell me where you land.

What is reasonable?

What is too far?

And what do you honestly expect a normal person to do in a life-or-death moment?

👇 Drop your thoughts in the comments.

––––––––––––––

FAFO isn’t about wanting violence.

It’s about understanding consequences.

If you believe good people shouldn’t be forced into moral traps created by criminals, check out the FAFO collection:

👉 Shop.MrColionNoir.com

And if you train, protect your hearing.

AKT1 Blackout hearing protection:

👉 Link in description

🔥 FAFO GEAR + AKT1 Blackouts (My Everyday Range Setup)

If you train, carry, or refuse to be a voluntary victim…

the FAFO mindset is exactly that: quiet strength and prepared courage.

Hats, hoodies, shirts, drinkware →

Use code FAFO for 15% off during the Holiday Sale.

AKT1 Blackouts — the “AirPods for shooters,” except they actually protect your hearing — are also available at the link.

If you’re serious about training smart — not just training loud — this one is worth your time.

Let’s talk about it in the comments.