Trump Faked Pro-Life — But Was the Whole Movement Fake Too? A Leader Gives the Honest Answer

If you'd like to support this work through a channel membership, here's the link!

My books are available on Amazon:

"A Christian Case Against Donald Trump" (2024)

"MAGA SeductionResisting the Debasement of the Christian Conscience" (2020)

For 30 years, Reverend Rob Schenck was one of the most powerful leaders inside the pro-life movement and the religious right. He was in the room. He knew the players. He helped build the platform. And now he's answering the question I've wanted to ask for a long time: Was it all a lie?

In this conversation, Schenck walks through his full journey — from true believer to what he calls a "penitential pilgrimage." He describes the moment a Republican operative told him directly, "We gave you the pro-life platform. Now you need to buy the rest of the package." He recounts watching Donald Trump at Pat Robertson's 80th birthday party in 2011 — learning to perform for evangelical audiences, holding up a Bible, reading the room. He shares what finally broke him at the 2016 Republican National Convention, when a colleague told him the plan was to support Trump, then "go into the men's room, puke our guts out, and get him elected."

This is not a political hit piece. It's a theological reckoning — with the movement, with Christian nationalism, and with the kind of hubris the gospel was never supposed to produce.

We cover:

— How the pro-life platform became a political bargain, not a moral conviction

— What Trump actually believes about abortion — and what Mike Pence privately told Schenck

— Why the movement "allowed itself to be corrupted" by power, privilege, and personal benefit

— The jail experience that cracked Schenck's certainty open for the first time

— What Dietrich Bonhoeffer taught him about reading the Bible against yourself

— Why absolute certitude is a form of pride — and what Christian humility actually demands

Rob Schenck is a former national leader of the anti-abortion movement and the religious right. He now serves as a theologian, author, and advocate working to repair what he helped build.