Judge Mathis on Why He Thinks The Menendez Brothers Should Be Let Free (Part 26)

Watch full interviews early, uncensored and adfree as a Member

Watch this Full Interview

--------

Judge Mathis expressed his belief that the Menendez brothers, who have been incarcerated for over three decades for the murder of their parents, should be released. Mathis acknowledges the gravity of their crimes but argues that the 35 years they’ve already served constitutes a full life sentence. During a previous interview, former prison guard Hector Bravo raised suspicions that the recent attention on the Menendez brothers, including media features and celebrity endorsements, carries political motivations—claims that Mathis refutes, highlighting the conflicting political views of different prosecutors. Mathis concurs that their crime was premeditated and heinous but emphasizes the alleged abuse as a mitigating factor, a claim he stands by despite skepticism over its credibility during trials. While acknowledging the severity of their actions, Mathis advocates for their release, believing they have atoned with the time already served.