Pt3: The Boy Who Never Came Home: The Case of Dylan Redwine

In Part 3 of The Boy Who Never Came Home: The Case of Dylan Redwine, Dr. Phil examines how a missing-child investigation became a murder prosecution and why investigators ultimately focused on Dylan’s father, Mark Redwine. After Dylan vanished during a court-ordered visit, investigators found blood evidence inside Mark’s home, including on furniture, flooring, and beneath a rug. Cadaver dogs later alerted in the home, washing machine, on clothing associated with Mark, and in his truck. Dr. Phil breaks down what this type of circumstantial evidence can—and cannot—prove, and why investigators look at the totality of evidence rather than any single clue. Dr. Phil also analyzes the behavioral pattern prosecutors argued was most revealing: Mark appeared to have an explanation for every suspicious detail, while maintaining the same core story as the evidence mounted. Was he helping investigators understand what happened to Dylan or explaining away the evidence? As the case heads to trial, Dr. Phil explores the prosecution’s theory, the defense’s challenges to the forensic evidence, and the jury’s difficult task in a case with no confession, no eyewitness, and no murder weapon. In the end, Mark Redwine was convicted of second-degree murder and child abuse resulting in death, bringing Dylan’s family long-delayed accountability.

This episode is made possible with the support of our sponsors.

Don’t wait! If you’re on Medicare or will be soon, reach out to ChapterCall(352)8450659 or go to to learn about your Medicare options and get help finding ways to save money.

RELAXIUM® Sleep is backed by a 90day guarantee, so you’ve got nothing to lose. Enjoy restful and refreshing sleep with drugfree, nonhabit forming RELAXIUM® Sleep. Get your riskfree bottle now. Go to or call 8009527770.

Experience a side of Dr. Phil McGraw you may have been missing as he provides critical information on some of the most important issues we face today. McGraw delves into the minds of the most exciting and accomplished people. From celebrities to ordinary people in extraordinary circumstances, to the world’s leading experts, every guest and topic is provocative, informative, and relevant.

Dr. Phil McGraw, one of the most well-known and trusted mental health professionals in the world, is the host of daytime TV’s top-rated program, Dr. Phil. This trailblazing and award-winning platform continues to provide the most comprehensive forum on mental health issues in the history of television. Dr. McGraw’s unique ability to take complicated and technical information and make it accessible and understandable to the general public has distinguished him both among viewers and within his profession.

Follow for more Dr. Phil & The Dr. Phil Podcast:

Dr. Phil Show

Apple Podcasts