Are Drones About to Replace Helicopters?

Get up to 30% off until May 19th; use code RYANMCBETH at checkout to get 10% off

Get my novel and Intel Life TShirt here

Will drones make jets and helicopters obsolete in warfare?

It's trendy to call weapons "obsolete," especially with drones capturing headlines. But let's slow down—are drones really capable of replacing piloted aircraft?

Infantry has faced the harshest conditions throughout history—trenches, machine guns, artillery barrages—yet no one ever calls infantry obsolete. Why? Because war still demands boots on the ground, making real-time decisions to secure territory.

The same principle applies to manned aircraft. Drones rely heavily on the electromagnetic spectrum, which can be disrupted by advanced electronic warfare from nations like China or Russia. Lose the spectrum, and drones become useless bricks falling from the sky.

Manned aircraft offer flexibility that drones simply can't match. Pilots can adapt instantly, overcome jamming, and improvise when unexpected problems arise.

Of course, drone technology is evolving:

HITL (Human in the Loop): Humans fully control drones.

HOTL (Human on the Loop): Drones act autonomously but await human approval.

HOOTL (Human out of the Loop): Completely autonomous drones capable of independent lethal decisions.

Fully autonomous systems, like Patriot missiles and the AEGIS combat system, already exist and make life-and-death choices without human intervention. Are we ready for aerial drones to do the same?

Despite their vulnerabilities—like helicopters during Vietnam (5,600 lost)—we still use manned aircraft for their unique capabilities, such as hovering, tight-space maneuvering, and unmatched close air support.

So, will drones ever completely replace jets and helicopters? Perhaps when we fully embrace autonomous combat drones. Until then, pilots provide resilience, adaptability, and essential human decision-making.

Because in warfare, as soon as you label something obsolete, someone finds a reason to keep it around. Just ask the infantry.

For uncensored video, check out my substack at:

Like my shirts? Get your own at:

Want a personalized greeting:

Watch all of my long form videos:

Twitter:

@ryanmcbeth

Instagram:

@therealryanmcbeth

BlueSky

@ryanmcbeth

Reddit:

/r/ryanmcbeth

Join the conversation:

Want to send me something?

Ryan McBeth Productions LLC

8705 Colesville Rd.

Suite 249

Silver Spring, MD 20910

USA