Supreme Court Upholds Curbs on Care for Transgender Minors

A divided US Supreme Court upheld a Tennessee law that outlaws certain controversial medical treatments for transgender children, preserving similar measures in two dozen states and dealing a fresh blow to LGBTQ rights.

Voting 6-3 along ideological lines, the justices ruled that the Tennessee law comports with the Constitution’s equal protection guarantee, rejecting arguments by families and former President Joe Biden’s administration.

June Grasso reports joins Bloomberg Intelligence to report on the latest decisions made by the supreme court .

“Our role is not to judge the wisdom, fairness, or logic of the law before us,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the court, “but only to ensure that it does not violate the equal protection guarantee of the Fourteenth Amendment.”

The ruling comes at what is already an especially fraught time for transgender Americans. Since taking office Jan. 20, President Donald Trump has declared that gender is immutable, called for banning transgender women from female sports and – with the Supreme Court’s backing – moved to expel transgender servicemembers from the military. His administration supported the Tennessee law.

Tennessee bans puberty blockers, hormone therapy and surgery for those under 18. Opponents say the law flies in the face of clinical guidelines for treating gender dysphoria, the condition characterized by distress over the incongruence between one’s gender identity and birth-assigned sex. Supporters say the law protects vulnerable children from risky and dangerous medical procedures.

The ruling “authorizes, without second thought, untold harm to transgender children and the parents and families who love them,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in dissent. She took the unusual step of reading a summary of her opinion from the bench to give it emphasis.

The private challengers included Samantha and Brian Williams, whose 15-year-old daughter said in a court statement that she had felt like she was “trapped” and “drowning” in her body before beginning treatments. The girl, represented by the American Civil Liberties Union, is known in court papers only as “L.W.”

“Today’s ruling is a devastating loss for transgender people, our families, and everyone who cares about the Constitution,” said Chase Strangio, an ACLU lawyer who argued the case, becoming the first openly trans person to do so at the Supreme Court.

The decision “is a punch in the gut for the transgender community,” said Maeve DuVally, a transgender-rights activist who previously worked as a spokeswoman for Goldman Sachs Group Inc. “Right now there’s a lot of anxiety amongst transgender children and their parents about whether they will have access to transgender medical care.” DuVally described such care as “life-saving.”

Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti, who led the defense of the law, hailed the ruling as a “historic Supreme Court win,” saying “the common sense of Tennessee voters prevailed over judicial activism.”

Gender Debate

The central question was whether the measure violated the Constitution by making treatments illegal when used for gender transition but not when used for other purposes.

Roberts said the measure didn’t discriminate on the basis of sex, as the challengers had contended. That would have required Tennessee to justify the measure under a demanding legal test known as “heightened scrutiny.”

Roberts said Tennessee cleared a lower bar known as “rational basis review.” The state “concluded that there is an ongoing debate among medical experts regarding the risks and benefits associated with administering puberty blockers and hormones to treat gender dysphoria, gender identity disorder, and gender incongruence,” he wrote.

--------

Watch Bloomberg Radio LIVE on YouTube

Weekdays 7am-6pm ET

Follow us on X

Subscribe to our Podcasts:

Bloomberg Daybreak

Bloomberg Surveillance

Bloomberg Intelligence

Balance of Power

Bloomberg Businessweek

Listen on Apple CarPlay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg Business app:

Apple CarPlay

Android Auto

Visit our YouTube channels:

Bloomberg Podcasts

Bloomberg Television

Bloomberg Originals