Is Pluto a Planet?

PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to

↓ More info below ↓

Sign Up on Patreon to get access to the Space Time Discord!

Sign up for the mailing list to get episode notifications and hear special announcements!

You know what a planet is, right? A big round thing that orbits a star. Uh, not so fast. The surprisingly vicious debate over the planetary status of Pluto has given us a fascinating glimpse into what a scientific definition really is. And perhaps the word planet is too vague to be used as a scientific definition at all.

Hosted by Matt O'Dowd

Written by Drew Rosen and Matt O'Dowd

Graphics by Leonardo Scholzer

Directed by: Andrew Kornhaber

Produced By: Kornhaber Brown

Check out the new Space Time Merch Store!

We love to classify things. Labels help us keep stuff organized in our heads. In science, categorization provides a fast and easy way to know the properties of a member of the group just by knowing what group it belongs to. Chemists group elements on the periodic table, those groups exhibit similar chemical behavior that reflect outer-shell electron number. Biologists group organisms by similar physical characteristics, and this taxonomy reflects genetic relationships. Astronomers are all about space taxonomy. We classify galaxies based on their shape, black holes based on how they feed, stars based on their colour and brightness, and planets by… well, by a set of criteria that has caused more tension and heartbreak than any made-up grouping scheme really should. Because a change in that scheme demoted Pluto from planet to not-planet. Today we’re going to settle whether this was reasonable, and whether we should keep the word “planet” at all.

Big Bang Supporters:

Alexander Tamas

Anton Lifshits

David Barnholdt

David Boyer

David Nicklas

Fabrice Eap

Juan Benet

Justin Lloyd

Matt Miller

Morgan Hough

Quasar Supporters:

Mark Heising

Mark Rosenthal

Vinnie Falco

Hypernova Supporters:

Chuck Zegar

Danton Spivey

Donal Botkin

Edmund Fokschaner

Hank S

John Hofmann

John R. Slavik

Jordan Young

Joseph Salomone

Matthew

Matthew O'Connor

Syed Ansar

Gamma Ray Burst Supporters:

Adrian Molyneux

Alec Zero

Andreas Nautsch

Bradley Jenkins

Brandon Labonte

Brian

Dan Warren

Daniel Lyons

David Behtala

DFaulk

Dustan Jones

Geoffrey Short

James Flowers

James Quintero

Jason

John Funai

John Michael Kerr

John Pollock

Jonah

Jonathan Nesfeder

Joseph Dillman

Josh Thomas

Kevin Lee

Kevin Warne

Kyle Hofer

Malte Ubl

Mark Vasile

Nick Virtue

Nick Wright

Paul Rose

Scott Gossett

Steve Bradshaw

Sigurd Ruud Frivik

Tim Stephani

Yurii Konovaliuk